The all-purpose cleaner shelf makes a big promise in its name, and most bottles only half keep it. Some are gentle daily sprays that surrender to a greasy stovetop; some are degreasers you would never aim at a coffee table; a few carry real disinfecting credentials with label conditions nobody reads. Picking one bottle without knowing which job you actually have is how cabinets fill up with regrets.
I compared sixteen all-purpose cleaners across the full spread: four from brand and grocery sites with prices verified directly today, and twelve Amazon mainstays. Seven of the sixteen were put through hands-on testing by Bob Vila's review team this year - I cite their verdicts where they apply and say so when a pick rides on its own track record instead.
Two honest notes before the list. First, disinfecting claims are label claims: they name specific germs, surfaces, and contact times, and nearly every cleaner here requires a water rinse on food-contact surfaces afterward. Second, plant-based and strong are not opposites, but they are not synonyms either - the natural picks earn their slots on daily grime, not on baked-on grease.
The shelf at a glance
Sixteen bottles, one table. The direct-store picks lead - those are the prices I verified today.
| Product | Format | Strength | Top pick for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Branch Basics Concentrate (branchbasics.com) | Concentrate | Fragrance-free system | One-bottle households; $55.00 |
| Puracy Spray (puracy.com) | Ready-to-use | 99%+ plant-based | Natural daily spray; $7.99 |
| Blueland Starter Set (blueland.com) | Tablet + bottle | No single-use plastic | Refill converts; $16.00 |
| Rebel Green Spray (grove.co) | Ready-to-use | Plant-based value | Budget natural; $4.99 |
| Sprayway Crazy Clean | Foaming aerosol | Clings to vertical grime | Backsplashes and shower walls |
| Mr. Clean Clean Freak | Continuous mist | Bob Vila's overall winner | Big surfaces fast |
| Simple Green | Concentrate | 1:10 dilution | Cost per clean |
| Puracy Concentrate | Concentrate | Plant-based gallon | Natural value play |
| Krud Kutter | Concentrate | Heavy degreasing | Range hoods and grills |
| Seventh Gen Wipes | Wipes | Thymol disinfecting | Doorknobs and switches |
| Clorox Clean-Up | Bleach spray | 30-second disinfecting | Bathrooms and bins |
| Mrs. Meyer's | Ready-to-use | Signature scents | Daily freshen-up |
| Method French Lavender | Ready-to-use | Plant-based middle | Counter-worthy default |
| Lysol Lemon Breeze | Ready-to-use | Cleans + disinfects | Kitchen-bath single bottle |
| Formula 409 | Ready-to-use | Kitchen grease | Post-cooking wipe-downs |
| Fabuloso Lavender 2X | Concentrate | Whole-room scent | Floors and fragrance fans |
Branch Basics The Concentrate (branchbasics.com)
One fragrance-free, plant- and mineral-based concentrate that dilutes into every cleaner in the house - $55.00 direct.
- One concentrate, every dilution
- Fragrance-free formula
- MadeSafe-certified ingredient screen
- $55.00 from branchbasics.com
Read More
Branch Basics built its whole system on a single idea: one concentrate, diluted different ways, replaces the all-purpose spray, the glass cleaner, the bathroom spray, and the floor solution. The Concentrate is fragrance-free and plant- and mineral-based, and the brand submits its formulas to MadeSafe's ingredient screening - a third-party certification, not just a marketing word. At $55.00 direct it is the biggest upfront number in this guide, but the bottle refills a spray bottle many times over, which changes the math quickly. For fragrance-sensitive households or anyone simplifying a cleaning cabinet down to one bottle, this is the cleanest starting point.
Puracy Multi-Surface Cleaner Spray, Green Tea & Lime (puracy.com)
The ready-to-use plant-based spray with a 99%+ natural formula - $7.99 direct.
- Ready-to-use, no diluting
- 99%+ plant-based formula
- Green tea & lime scent
- $7.99 from puracy.com
Read More
If the Branch Basics concentrate is the system play, this is the grab-and-go answer from the same brand family. Puracy's ready-to-use Multi-Surface Cleaner sprays straight from the bottle in a green tea and lime scent, with a formula the brand describes as over 99% natural. Bob Vila's tested roundup put Puracy's multi-surface line in its food-contact conversation - with the label-condition caveat that food-prep surfaces still get a rinse - and this spray is the everyday expression of that formula. At $7.99 direct it is the cheapest way to try the brand.
Blueland Multi-Surface Starter Set (blueland.com)
The refill-tablet system: a reusable bottle plus a tablet that dissolves in tap water - $16.00 one-time.
- Tablet + tap water system
- Reusable bottle, no single-use plastic
- Compact refill storage
- $16.00 one-time from blueland.com
Read More
Blueland's pitch is packaging: instead of shipping water around the country, you buy the bottle once and drop a small tablet into tap water when it runs empty. The Multi-Surface Starter Set - bottle plus tablet - is $16.00 one-time from the brand's site, and refills after that are just tablets, which store flat in a drawer. The cleaner itself handles counters and everyday grime rather than baked-on disasters, which is the honest scope for the format. For anyone whose real complaint is the pile of empty plastic bottles, this system removes the pile.
Rebel Green All Purpose Spray (grove.co)
A plant-based, scented all-purpose spray from Grove Collaborative's shelves - $4.99.
- Plant-based formula
- Several scent options
- Grove Collaborative staple
- $4.99 from grove.co
Read More
Rebel Green is the budget natural pick on Grove Collaborative's shelves: a plant-based all-purpose spray in a rotating cast of scents, priced at $4.99. There is no editor panel behind this one - it earns the slot as the proven, inexpensive plant-based option you can toss into a Grove order without thinking. It handles counters, tables, and daily wipe-downs; like the other gentle plant formulas here, it is not the bottle you reach for first on a greasy range hood. At this price, it is the easiest way to test whether a natural spray covers your household's daily load.
Sprayway Crazy Clean All Purpose Cleaner
The anchor pick: a 19 oz foaming aerosol that clings to vertical surfaces and dissolves greasy film - Sprayway's No. 31.
- Foaming aerosol clings to walls
- 19 oz net weight can
- Non-abrasive foam action
- Sprayway's classic No. 31
Read More
The anchor of this guide is a can that has outlived most cleaning trends. Sprayway's No. 31 Crazy Clean is a foaming all-purpose aerosol - 19 oz net weight in the can, per the maker's technical data sheet - and the foam is the whole trick: it clings to vertical surfaces like backsplashes, shower walls, and appliance doors instead of running straight down, which gives the surfactants time to work on greasy film. The foam is non-abrasive, so it is kind to finishes that a scouring powder would haze. It carries a light floral scent rather than a chemical sting. For sticky kitchen film and bathroom grime on upright surfaces, nothing else in this guide works quite the same way.
Mr. Clean Clean Freak Multi-Surface Cleaning Mist
Bob Vila's tested overall pick: a continuous-mist spray that beat grease and soap scum in their tests.
- Bob Vila tested overall pick
- Power Nozzle: targeted or continuous mist
- Safe for multiple surfaces
- Rinse food-contact surfaces after
Read More
When Bob Vila's team tested all-purpose cleaners head to head, Mr. Clean's Clean Freak came out as their overall winner. Tester Katie Barton credited the Power Nozzle sprayer - it switches between a targeted stream and a continuous mist - and its performance on grease and soap scum across surfaces. Their one knock on the line: only its lavender scent carries EPA Safer Choice certification. Like most cleaners in this class, food-contact surfaces need a water rinse after use. The mist format genuinely changes how you clean big surfaces - a few sweeps fog a whole countertop.
Simple Green All-Purpose Cleaner Concentrate
Bob Vila's value pick: the classic concentrated cleaner that dilutes 1:10 for everyday jobs.
- Bob Vila tested value pick
- Concentrate dilutes 1:10
- Decades-long track record
- Works across floor types
Read More
Simple Green is the bottle your parents had under the sink, and Bob Vila's testing gave it the value slot for a reason: the concentrate dilutes 1:10 for everyday cleaning, so one bottle stretches into many spray bottles of working solution. Their team noted it handled grime across surfaces without the harsh-chemical smell of legacy degreasers. The dilution dial is the skill to learn - stronger for greasy jobs, weaker for daily wipe-downs. On pure cost per cleaning session, nothing else tested comes close.
Puracy Natural Multi-Surface Cleaner Concentrate
Bob Vila's food-surface category pick: a plant-based concentrate, with the usual rinse caveat on food-contact surfaces.
- Bob Vila food-surface category
- Plant-based concentrate
- Makes a gallon of cleaner
- Green tea & lime scent
Read More
Bob Vila's roundup slotted Puracy's concentrate in its food-surface category - their framing, with the standard label condition that food-contact surfaces get rinsed after cleaning, which applies to essentially every product in this guide. The plant-based formula dilutes to make roughly a gallon of working cleaner, so it sits between Simple Green's workhorse economics and the ready-to-use sprays' convenience. The green tea and lime scent is one of the most pleasant in the group. If you want concentrate value with a natural-leaning ingredient list, this is the bottle.
Krud Kutter Original Concentrated Cleaner Degreaser
Bob Vila's degreaser pick: the concentrate for range hoods, grills, and garage-level grime.
- Bob Vila tested degreaser pick
- Concentrated formula
- Cuts heavy kitchen grease
- Multi-surface despite the name
Read More
Krud Kutter's name tells you its job, and Bob Vila's testing confirmed it: their team named it the degreaser of the group after it powered through the kind of baked-on kitchen grease that laughs at gentler sprays. The concentrated format means you control the strength - full for the range hood and the grill, diluted for counters. Despite the aggressive name, it is water-based and works across most household surfaces. This is the bottle to keep for the jobs the daily spray cannot finish.
Seventh Generation Disinfecting Multi-Surface Wipes
EPA-registered thymol disinfecting wipes - kills 99.9% of the germs named on the label.
- EPA-registered disinfectant
- Thymol active ingredient
- Kills 99.9% of label-listed germs
- Wipe format, no bottle needed
Read More
Seventh Generation's wipes are the disinfecting option for people who read ingredient lists: the active is thymol, a thyme-oil component, and the product is EPA-registered to kill 99.9% of the specific germs identified on its label when used as directed - label language matters here, because disinfection claims are surface- and contact-time-specific, not a blanket promise. The wipe format trades spray-and-wipe flexibility for grab-one convenience on doorknobs, switches, and counters. For households wanting a plant-derived disinfectant route, this is the mainstream answer.
Clorox Clean-Up Cleaner + Bleach
Bob Vila's disinfecting pick: disinfects in 30 seconds per the label and beat heavy soap scum in their test.
- Bob Vila tested disinfecting pick
- Disinfects in 30 seconds (label)
- Bleach-based formula
- Rinse food-contact surfaces after
Read More
Clorox Clean-Up is the heavy hitter Bob Vila's team picked for disinfecting: the label promises disinfection in 30 seconds on the organisms it lists, and in their tests it beat heavy soap scum that defeated gentler formulas. Two honest conditions: it is a bleach product, so it needs sensible ventilation and it can mark fabrics and some finishes; and food-contact surfaces need a rinse afterward. Keep it for bathrooms, trash areas, and the genuinely grimy jobs rather than the daily counter pass. When you need certainty rather than gentleness, this is the bottle.
Mrs. Meyer's Clean Day Multi-Surface Everyday Cleaner
Bob Vila's scent pick: garden-inspired fragrances in a cruelty-free everyday spray.
- Bob Vila tested scent pick
- Garden-inspired fragrances
- Cruelty-free formula
- Everyday-strength cleaner
Read More
Mrs. Meyer's turned cleaning scent into a feature rather than something to apologize for, and Bob Vila's testing slotted it accordingly: their team named it the scent pick of the group. The everyday cleaner is cruelty-free and handles counters and daily grime in fragrances like lavender, lemon verbena, and basil - the scent catalog rotates seasonally, which keeps people loyal. Judge it as a daily freshen-up spray rather than a degreaser and it is exactly as good as its reputation.
Method All-Purpose Cleaner Spray, French Lavender
The design-forward plant-based spray that made natural cleaning mainstream - cut grease in Bob Vila's test.
- Plant-based, design-forward bottle
- French lavender scent
- Handled grease in Bob Vila's test
- Widely available
Read More
Method is the brand that proved a plant-based cleaner could sit on the counter instead of under it. In Bob Vila's testing, the all-purpose spray handled grease credibly for a natural-leaning formula, and the French lavender scent remains one of the best in the category. The bottle is recyclable and the formula is biodegradable per the brand. It occupies the sensible middle: nicer to live with than the legacy chemicals, stronger than the watery naturals. A safe default for everyday counters and tables.
Lysol All-Purpose Cleaner Spray, Lemon Breeze
The classic disinfecting all-purpose spray - kills 99.9% of germs listed on its label while it cleans.
- Disinfects while it cleans
- Kills 99.9% of label-listed germs
- Lemon Breeze scent
- Trusted legacy formula
Read More
Lysol's all-purpose spray is the two-birds bottle: it cleans grease and grime while disinfecting the surfaces the label covers - the 99.9% figure refers to the specific germs listed on the label under label contact times, which is the honest way to read any disinfecting claim. Lemon Breeze is the classic scent. It sits between Clorox Clean-Up's bleach muscle and the gentler daily sprays: stronger disinfection credentials than the naturals, less aggressive chemistry than bleach. A sensible single bottle for kitchens and baths.
Formula 409 Multi-Surface Cleaner, Original
The original grease-cutting kitchen spray - a straightforward formula that has stocked cabinets for decades.
- Original kitchen degreasing spray
- Cuts grease and food messes
- No-frills formula
- Large bottle value
Read More
Formula 409 is the definition of a cabinet staple: an original-scent multi-surface spray built for kitchen grease and food messes, sold in generous bottles at fair prices. It does not carry the natural positioning of the plant-based picks or the fragrance ambitions of Mrs. Meyer's - it is the straightforward middle. For stovetop splatter and post-cooking wipe-downs it has decades of household evidence behind it, even if it has no fresh editor verdict this year. The dependable default.
Fabuloso Multi-Purpose Cleaner, Lavender 2X
The 56 oz lavender icon: a 2X concentrated multi-purpose cleaner that leaves whole rooms smelling clean.
- 2X concentrated formula
- Signature lavender scent
- 56 oz bottle
- Floors to counters
Read More
Fabuloso is the scent-event cleaner: the lavender 2X concentrated formula dilutes for floors or works straight on counters, and one session perfumes a whole floor of the house - which fans love and scent-sensitive households should weigh honestly. The 56 oz bottle is serious value for the volume. It cleans everyday grime rather than baked-on grease, and like the rest of this class, food-contact surfaces get a rinse after use. If the smell of clean matters as much as the clean itself, this is the bottle with the cult following.

What the testing showed
Bob Vila's review team, with tester Katie Barton, put this category through hands-on trials this year, and their scorecard maps cleanly onto this list. Mr. Clean's Clean Freak took the overall crown - Barton credited the continuous-mist sprayer's coverage and its wins on grease and soap scum; their spec table notes that only the line's lavender scent is EPA Safer Choice certified, and that food-contact surfaces need a rinse after use. Simple Green took value on the strength of its 1:10 dilution economics, Clorox Clean-Up took disinfecting after beating heavy soap scum with a 30-second label claim, Krud Kutter took the degreaser slot, and Mrs. Meyer's took scent. Puracy's multi-surface line anchored their food-surface conversation, always with the rinse caveat.
Where I diverge from their ordering is at the top: my anchor is the Sprayway Crazy Clean aerosol, because the foaming format solves a problem the pump sprays physically cannot - staying put on vertical surfaces long enough to work. It is a specialist tool, but the specialist jobs are exactly where the daily sprays fail.
Disinfecting claims, decoded
Four bottles in this guide carry disinfection credentials, and the fine print is the product. Seventh Generation's wipes use thymol - a thyme-derived active - and are EPA-registered to kill 99.9% of the germs named on the label, at label contact times. Clorox Clean-Up's label promises disinfection in 30 seconds on its listed organisms. Lysol's all-purpose spray disinfects while it cleans, against its label's list. These are regulated, verifiable claims - but they are also specific ones, tied to organisms, surfaces, and wet contact time, and they never cover a casual wipe-and-dry.
Two rules keep disinfection honest at home. Read the contact time on your bottle and keep the surface wet for the full count - most people wipe dry far too early. And rinse any food-contact surface with water after using these or any other cleaners in the guide, plant-based included. The label is not being fussy; it is the instructions for the claim to be true.
Concentrate or ready-to-use?
A third of this guide is concentrate, and the choice is really about your tolerance for one extra step. Concentrates - Branch Basics, Simple Green, Puracy's bottle, Krud Kutter, and Fabuloso - ask you to dilute before cleaning, and in exchange they slash cost per use, plastic per clean, and storage space. Simple Green's 1:10 dilution means one bottle becomes ten spray bottles of working cleaner; Puracy's makes roughly a gallon. Ready-to-use sprays cost more per session but never ask anything of you, and the mist and aerosol formats add coverage tricks a diluted refill cannot copy. My honest advice: keep one concentrate for floors and big jobs, one ready-to-use spray by the kitchen counter, and skip owning both formats of the same chemistry.
How I'd choose
If you want one system to replace everything, Branch Basics' concentrate is my top pick - one fragrance-free bottle that dilutes into every cleaner in the house, with third-party ingredient screening behind it. If you want the simplest possible upgrade, Puracy's $7.99 spray is the cheapest good answer. Blueland wins if the plastic pile is your actual grievance, and Rebel Green is the no-brainer budget natural.
On the Amazon side, match the bottle to the job that keeps defeating you. Greasy vertical surfaces and shower walls: Sprayway's foam. Big daily wipe-downs: Mr. Clean's mist, the editors' overall winner. Maximum economy: Simple Green's concentrate. Heavy grease: Krud Kutter. Real disinfecting: Clorox Clean-Up for bathrooms, Seventh Generation's wipes for a plant-derived route, Lysol for the middle. Scent as a feature: Mrs. Meyer's for the garden fragrances, Fabuloso for whole-room lavender. And Method or Formula 409 when you just want the dependable default.
Whatever you pick, the boring habits matter more than the bottle: let disinfectants sit their full contact time, rinse food-prep surfaces, and keep the degreaser away from delicate finishes. Do that and any of these sixteen earns its shelf space.
The responses below are not provided, commissioned, reviewed, approved, or otherwise endorsed by any financial entity or advertiser. It is not the advertiser’s responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.